Our website showcases a small sample of the products available at The Toy Chest. Please visit us at 335 High Street, Hope, NJ to experience our "Most Unusual Store", as it was intended... in person!

    You have no items in your shopping cart.

Classic Toys

Classic Metal Potholder Loom $14.99
Weave a surprise for the kitchen with this fun filled pot holder kit. With 100% Cotton loops and amazing colors, you are sure to create a usable work of art! Additional loops sold separately. Ages 5 & up. Measures 7.5 x 1.75 x 7.5 WARNING: Strangulation hazard. Long chord. Not suitable for children under 36 months.
$14.99
Duncan Yo-Yo Butterfly Green, Red, or Blue $5.99
The Original and best selling string yo-yo of all time! A favorite for over 60 years, the Butterfly® offers a wide shape that makes landing the yo-yo on the string much easier. It features a flared shape, steel axle and durable plastic body that can withstand impact. It's great for learning the basics of yo-yoing! Colors may vary... please inform us of your preference and we will do our best to accomodate your request.
$5.99
Electronic Baseball $21.99
This 70s sensation is back just like you remember, now with improved sound effects! Get ready to pitch, hit, and run around the bases to score your homerun! Features 1 or 2 player game and different play modes. Requires 3 x AAA batteries, included. Measures 8 x 5.25 x 1.5. Ages 8+
$21.99
Electronic Basketball $21.99
Its Back! The Original Game Sensation, with Improved Sound Effects! Use the arrows to move around the court to get your perfect shot! Press the SHOOT button and sink the basket. Features 1 or 2 player game and 2 different play modes. Assorted colors and styles. Product measures 8x5.25x1.5. Ages 8+
$21.99
Electronic Football $21.99
Its Back! The Original Game Sensation, with Improved Sound Effects! Get ready to run, kick and move forward or sideways to avoid tacklers! Features 1 or 2 player game and 2 different play modes. Assorted colors and styles. Product measures 8x5.25x1.5. Ages 8+
$21.99
Etch A Sketch $15.99
The one and only original Etch a Sketch! Your child will initially be drawn in by the unique interface, and will be encouraged as they see themselves grow more proficient with it, increasing their dexterity and creative flair. The possibilities are too numerous to list, as it does not necessarily have to be a stand alone toy; perhaps it could become a treasure map, or your child could create mazes for their friends to solve. Simply the act of using this classic toy is a joy of itself. Everyone's favourite drawing tool - Classic Etch A Sketch. Suitable for Ages 4+
$15.99
Fisher Price Chatter Phone $19.99
This spunky little phone is sure to captivate any audience. With its rolling eyes, ringing old school rotary dial, wheels that spin and a mouth that just loves to chatter, this pull along telephone will have little ones chatting away all day long! Since 1930, Fisher-Price has been in business to create toys that fascinate and stimulate a child's imagination. Ages 12 months + Measures 9.12 x 7.5 x 5.62
$19.99
Fisher Price Record Player $29.99
Sold Out
Originally introduced in 1971, this endearing classic is now available again. With all of your party favorites, the music box record player will make everyone want to get up and dance! Features 5 discs with 10 classic songs to keep you moving to the beat. A carrying handle makes for easy transport and a convenient storage slot holds your records stored nicely even when you are on the go! Since 1930, Fisher-Price has been in business to create toys that fascinate and stimulate a child's imagination. Ages over 18 months. Measures 11.5 x 5.5 x 10.75
$29.99
Fisher Price TV Radio $19.99
Sold Out
It's the Farmer-in-the-Dell! Introduced in 1966, the Fisher-Price Two Tune Music Box TV has been stimulating the eyes and ears of children for generations. Just wind the knob to hear the melody while whimsical scenes scroll across the window. Since 1930, Fisher-Price has been in business to create toys that fascinate and stimulate a child's imagination. Ages over 18 months. Measures 10.12 x 3.12 x 8.12
$19.99
Jack in a Box $24.99
Sold Out
Schylling's Jack in the Boxes are sure to bring a smile to every child's face. Turn the handle to hear a fun song and POP! An adorable plush figure pop's out! Push them back in and close the lid to start the fun again. Plays Pop Goes the Weasel. Features our famous Jester plush puppet and classic art. As seen in the movies and on TV! Measures 5.75 x 5.75 x 6.5 Ages over 18 months.
$24.99
Magnetic Gyro Wheel by Schylling $4.99
It's magic! This amazing gyro wheel spins with great precision, even upside down! A quick flick of the wrist sends the wheel spinning! The gyro wheel spins so fast it becomes a twirling whirling blur! No batteries required! Measures 11.75 x 2.5 x 1.75 Ages 3 & up. WARNING: CHOKING HAZARD Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
$4.99
Mr. Potato Head ~ Classic $9.99
Discover all the possibilities of the wonderful and wacky Mr. Potato Head Toy! With 11 different accessories included, kids can use their imaginations for lots of creative play when they mix and match the parts in all kinds of ways to create their own customized tater. Little hands will have so much fun making their favorite tater friend look silly by rearranging parts and creating mixed-up faces. Most parts are compatible with other Mr. Potato Head and Mrs. Potato Head toys (sold separately). Mr. Potato Head and all related characters are trademarks of Hasbro.
$9.99
Original Slinky Walking Spring Toy $5.99
Sold Out
Everyone wants a Slinky! Slinky is the original walking spring toy. Watch your Slinky walk its way down stairs or just juggle it balk and forth in your hands. The Original Slinky features a metal slinky spring toy. Each slinky comes individually packaged in a box.
$5.99
Popeye The Sailer Collection Figures Gift Set $24.99
Popeye and the gang are all here in this treasured, collectible boxed set! Fully bendable and poseable you'll want a set to play with and a set to display! Includes Wimpy, Popeye, Olive Oyl, Brutus and Swee' Pea Bendables
$24.99
Retro Mini Soldier 60 Pack Action Figures by Schylling $4.99
Contains two armies of classic toy soldiers. One green army and one brown army. 60 pieces in all.
$4.99
    1 2 
21 Item(s)